Yeah, I saw the Manila By Night opening. I suppose this is O'Hara's reply--both are more different than they are similar, I think. Or, O'Hara is responding to Bernal's cynicism--and Manila By Night is the most complete expression of Bernal's cynicism--by showing characters that, however depraved or corrupt or perverse, still have his (O'Hara's) sympathies.
Mely Tagasa--suddenly I'm in awe of her. Kastilyong Buhangin, this pic--she does melodramas better than Ricky Lee can, at least when O'Hara directs them. Have they done anything else together?
And I can't believe Sergio Lobo and O'Hara worked together! The shadows here are velvety; you could almost sink into them. The lighting is harsh, when it's not seductively soft, and there's a real look to this picture that owes nothing to either Romy Vitug or Carding Baltazar. Have they done anything else together?!
And that beautiful ambiguity--I'm talking about Mande's eventual departure. It's foreshadowed by his ex-girlfriend's visit (Laurice Guillen?), then Claudia's full confession of love (which he never hears, being asleep), and finally his scene with the American. We're all ready for the rejection, but what's that pause he does before he comes in and gives it to her straight? Is he trying to steel himself for the task? Because he finds it too difficult, or because he still loves her? Or is he thinking this is the best way to break things off, by being such a bastard? Maybe not the third, but O'Hara teases us with these throwaway moments, so fleeting you can miss them if you blink...
Looking at O'Hara's filmography. He did this film after Ibulong Mo sa Puso (seen that, Jojo?) and before the great Condemned. Seems to me he's been making variations on Maynila sa Mga Kuko ng Liwanag all throughout the first half of the '80s, and many of them can stand, well, not side-by-side, but at least in the same room as that film...