Unfortunately even with a low-priced HD player, its common argument that the only way to fully enjoy HD is with expensive 50" or higher HDTV hooked to a expensive 7.1 TrueHD reciever. J8P will find little benefit from cheap players compared to SD DVD players on small 480 resolution TVs. And the price of HD disc is another turn off compared to SD DVDs.
I agree with your audio, that to fully enjoy it, got to have those true hd receivers. But to me this is already mid to high end setup, only selected few can afford this. True the J6P will not get these receivers. However, I dont really agree that one should have a 50 inch to truly enjoy pq of hd. I only have a 32 and the pq on "SOME" titles are really far from sddvds. Some hd titles look really good, it blows away standard dvds. Just by pausing the scene you will see the big difference..However, I dont have those high end upscalers, like Denons or those with Reon chips to compare. But on regular cheap upscalers the difference is huge on some titles.
I think the real impt issue here is the transfer these studios are making. To me, investing/buying into hd, ALL titles should be at least 4 1/2 stars and above. It should really blow away dvds in terms of PQ. This will only be the reason J6P will buy into HD. Some titles are not even worth the upgrade to hd, upconvertion is just fine..So with players pricing this low, its a great start for HD. Imagine without toshiba/venturer/hddvd lowering prices like this, Sony and others/bluray will still have those 1000 dollar players. Grabbing us by the throat. There is no way there will be a 499 dollar ps3 if not for toshiba. Low/middle income groups (like me) get to enjoy hd NOW..This is the positive thing for me. Thats why I rarely buy those new releases at over 25 dollars bec I find them nga too expensive. I go for mostly catalog at 19.95. Actually I like catalogs better, Die hard, star wars, Indy, just to name a few..Unless those new releases are really great, I buy them right away. So far like bourne ultimatum, transformers and I heard Ratoutille (how do you spell this) is good, Pirates 3 (just bec I havent watched it and just to complete my pirates bluray collection) Some people said this movie sucks, Oh well.. I would get these for day/date releases at those premium prices. This is just me tho..
I think it will take years for HD to be accepted..It has to do the following quickly..
1. Lower prices of players (99 dollar) levels.
2. Lower prices of discs, to levels of dvds.
3. When there are more and more players being sold, phase out dvd releases on those day/date movie releases. It will only be in hd. People will be forced to buy those 99 dollar hd players
4. Lower hdtv prices.
5. Studios having great transfers
To me all of this has to happen for this to be a success.