To PinoyDVD's video experts: your comments please?
Reply (to the post of porkepik, see below):
Na, not that it's a realtek problem, i got the Asus O!Play with a lowe realtek chips set, the image is the same or not better than my Elektron 606 ... it's the firmware default setting, but you can change it to what ever you like
Originally Posted by porkepik View Post:
Hey,
So i've decided to put the Popcorn C-200 (fw 091007) and Xtreamer (fw 1.3.01) to the test, and honestly i wasn't expecting that there would be so much differences between the two
Plugged the devices to same TV (Toshiba Regza FullHD 47") which has exact same settings for all HDMI inputs, and these settings come from long debates on AVForums, and personal tests so i know they're good...
So just switching between hdmi sources, the testing began with all sorts of videos. From the 700MB xvid to the 720p MKVs, finishing with untouched bluray m2ts, the exact same behaviour was here: colours are severely washed out on xtreamer with less details. There is way more image noise too.
The most obvious thing is people's flesh look lively on the C-200, while they have a brownish 'effect' on xtreamer
Can't imagine what people with 60" high quality pioneer Tv or videoprojectors would find
Have any other people made tests?
Anyone made comparisons between realtek models?
Someone on avsforums reported that his asus o!play (realtek 1073) had bad video image compared to his A110, i would tend to believe him now.
I checked on xtreamer forums, found 1 post about bad dvd quality, no one answered yet...
I know one device is almost 3 times the price of the other, but this is about sigma 864x VS realtek 1283 here.
There is no colour management in xtreamer settings, just brightness and contrast, the C-200 only has choice between 0-255 and 16-235 range, so no risk of missing on any forgotten setting...